Brownie Reese’s Cookie Cups

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (3,946 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)

Close ×

A subscriber sent me a message bringing these to my attention.

This ideas has also made it's way around Pinterest and I think original may come from here:

You can use from and recipes, but I used a brownie mix and ready-made dough.

These are big and one of them a very large serving for someone, you may want to cut them in half to serve them.

graphics by Lucas Rousseau
Vocals by Rosetta Chan
Music by Jason Shaw (Audionautix)

«« Previous post
Marijuana Nonna – Best Medical Marijuana Butterleaf Flour Recipe for Brownies & Cookies
Next post »»
How to Make Valentine’s Day Brownies!

81 Comments for Brownie Reese’s Cookie Cups

  1. Helen Ahajjam on April 26, 2013: (Reply)

    Mmmm, Looks Good!

  2. gymnastambyr on April 27, 2013: (Reply)

    you made me want some brownies and reese cups and oreos !

  3. iheartmyfriendss on May 1, 2013: (Reply)

    I think she should move to Pennsylvania ;p

  4. Brutaluta on May 2, 2013: (Reply)

    Very cool! Thanks for posting! 🙂 GOD BLESS <3 PRAISE JESUS 🙂

  5. Lauren Mroczka on May 12, 2013: (Reply)

    Maybe could u make a brookie (cookie and brownie) made into a cupcake

  6. Melissa Newton on May 19, 2013: (Reply)

    maybe a phantom of the opera cake

  7. gerbilfight on May 20, 2013: (Reply)

    At my school, we call the oreo, cookie, and brownie cupcakes “slutty
    brownies”. They are absolutely delicious.

  8. Claire C on May 22, 2013: (Reply)

    Im making these today!!

  9. Many Monstur on May 26, 2013: (Reply)

    I’m making these today!! :3

  10. Norma Scott on May 28, 2013: (Reply)

    Recess vs. Oreo which one will u choose

  11. SteffyPoo Turbin on May 29, 2013: (Reply)

    i like this it seem so easier than the other youtube recipes aint nobody
    got time for making everything from scratch……

  12. Alexr7352 on May 31, 2013: (Reply)

    I want one right now

  13. Cookie Pony on June 1, 2013: (Reply)

    we don’t have those Reese things in Finland :'< Can I use peanutbutter

  14. SingingCrafts on June 4, 2013: (Reply)

    I tried these last night and they are delicious. Thank you for this recipe

  15. Sanjana Rg on June 8, 2013: (Reply)

    you could try making your own! just search reese’s on youtube 🙂

  16. lovePINK96 on June 19, 2013: (Reply)

    so u just basically made mini slutty brownies

  17. HuntForWaffles on June 25, 2013: (Reply)

    Try finding a chocolate/peanut butter candy, but if you cant, just peanut
    butter should work fine.

  18. 909mommy on June 28, 2013: (Reply)

    Tryed making these today and it was good fresh out the oven but hrs later
    it was hard as a rock!! What did I do wrong?? :/

  19. Meagan Nudge on June 28, 2013: (Reply)

    there’s also a few videos on youtube about making homemade peanut butter
    cups 🙂

  20. GothyPingu on June 28, 2013: (Reply)

    overbake them, maybe?

  21. Irene Teigen on July 1, 2013: (Reply)

    Can you use just regular peanutbutter inside?

  22. Kittys AndDoggys on July 2, 2013: (Reply)

    that would be good well i think so

  23. Claire C on July 3, 2013: (Reply)

    I made these and they were AMAZING!!!!

  24. Claire C on July 3, 2013: (Reply)

    For me it was kinda hard to take them out with out liners but i made some
    with liners and it was really easy to take out and every thing was together

  25. Camryn Bell on July 8, 2013: (Reply)

    You should have lightly soaked the Oreos in some milk before making this
    and they wouldn’t be as hard

  26. Abby Santana on July 14, 2013: (Reply)

    Can you substitute the cookie bottom for just the brownie?

  27. Jayden schouten on July 16, 2013: (Reply)


  28. yohana argueta on July 19, 2013: (Reply)

    NO move to New York!!!!plzzzz

  29. Adilene Martinez on July 20, 2013: (Reply)


  30. Willow Blaine on July 22, 2013: (Reply)

    NO move to Washington!!

  31. AteTinaB1321 on July 27, 2013: (Reply)

    My friends made something like this for my birthday. Instead of baking it
    individually, they had it in a full baking dish. They started with a layer
    of cookie, then a layer of Nutella and peanut butter, a layer of Oreo
    cookies, and lastly a layer of brownies. They doubled the layers to make a
    monstrous dessert we simply named “Diabetes”.

  32. Elric Emric VII on July 28, 2013: (Reply)

    I saw this on this girls channel way back i think her name was danille?

  33. saphirejewelscoward on July 30, 2013: (Reply)

    haha, I know this is a dumb question but was it good?

  34. Abby Santana on July 31, 2013: (Reply)

    This was uploaded on my birthday 😀 Fate is calling to me!

  35. Rachael Short on July 31, 2013: (Reply)

    YES!!! PLEASE!!!

  36. mygnomies1 on August 1, 2013: (Reply)

    stop spamming plz

  37. Maria L on August 1, 2013: (Reply)

    Okay I’m trying this out tomorrow hopefully! My cousin is in love with
    recess peanut butter cups! He turned 16 tomorrow, so if I make it hopefully
    he likes them!

  38. Cailey James on August 1, 2013: (Reply)

    that looks so good. but I would rather the ones with the reeses better.
    your recipe was the best for any type of reeses filled cookie or brownie
    I’ve seen on youtube.

  39. Maxime Pluimers on August 6, 2013: (Reply)

    Hmmm, never had Reese butter cups, how do they taste like?

  40. HowAmI | Its Satan on August 6, 2013: (Reply)

    Chocolate and Peanut-butter together

  41. HowAmI | Its Satan on August 6, 2013: (Reply)

    I will try this out Thank You yoyomax12 :}

  42. Mitsuki12131 on August 6, 2013: (Reply)

    OMG. Im shocked xD They re absolutely heavenly O_O(reese peanut butter cups)

  43. Maxime Pluimers on August 6, 2013: (Reply)

    I live in Holland, unfortunately we don’t have those here 🙁 But they look
    delicious 🙂

  44. 16spatulaz on August 7, 2013: (Reply)

    can you put brownie mix under the reese’s instead of cookie dough

  45. BeepBoop4 on August 8, 2013: (Reply)

    HOW DO YOU SURVIVE?! Lol, they’re amazing, it’s like chocolate peanut
    butter HEAVEN

  46. Maxime Pluimers on August 10, 2013: (Reply)

    Now I really want them D: Sigh… Americans are lucky o/

  47. Nuran Mirdha on August 16, 2013: (Reply)

    Haha same!! A bunch of the “health-obsessed moms” have taken to the
    administrator’s office to ban the sale of the praised slutty brownies XD

  48. Dylan Keddie on August 17, 2013: (Reply)

    thats what most ppl call them

  49. greg wesley on August 18, 2013: (Reply)

    These were amazing make sure you put whipped cream on it

  50. greg wesley on August 18, 2013: (Reply)

    These were amazing make sure you put whipped cream on it

  51. Sam Simonds on August 19, 2013: (Reply)

    what is up with the intro?

  52. Alex Skinner on August 20, 2013: (Reply)

    NO move to Georgia! PLEEEEEEASE!

  53. CatBug on August 20, 2013: (Reply)

    I love you so much ;_;

  54. CatBug on August 20, 2013: (Reply)

    I’ve never had one of those 🙁

  55. William Obeng Jr. on August 20, 2013: (Reply)

    Stahppp, move to Boston, Massachusetts ! I would bring my friends all the
    time !

  56. MaferAteYourCookies on August 24, 2013: (Reply)

    I loved the intro

  57. DawgTycoon on August 25, 2013: (Reply)

    I like how I got here from Malcolm in the Middle

  58. Anna Schneider on August 25, 2013: (Reply)

    NO!!! MOVE TO MISSOURI!!! ^u^

  59. Bella S on August 28, 2013: (Reply)

    no! move to Nebraska!!! ^-^

  60. ddogg845 on August 30, 2013: (Reply)

    i must stop watching these

  61. Nexarianz on August 30, 2013: (Reply)

    OMG this looks sooooo good….. I’ve just gained 10lbs watching this. lol

  62. thenazizombie1 on August 31, 2013: (Reply)

    I know it might be too soon but, will you marry me?

  63. fall22123 on August 31, 2013: (Reply)

    I made these today…yum. 360 calories each though. I think I’ll freeze
    some so I don’t eat them all. The cookie seemed to rise up the sides and
    form a kind of bowl. Also, the chocolate around the peanut butter cup
    seemed to disappear. It must have been absorbed by the cookie and brownie.

  64. Arthur Kirkland on September 1, 2013: (Reply)

    Just start a chain of shops around the country for Pete’s sake.

  65. Samantha Martinez on September 2, 2013: (Reply)

    Thank you they tasted amazing

  66. Cameron Epperson on September 4, 2013: (Reply)

    She’s Canadian

  67. Baking 101 on September 8, 2013: (Reply)


  68. Aaron Johnson on September 14, 2013: (Reply)

    I’m going to go to the store and buy some ingredients right now ….

  69. itsEmily on September 15, 2013: (Reply)

    NO Move to Toronto!

  70. Banana Mustache Army on September 20, 2013: (Reply)

    u know i’d rather just eat the cookie dough!

  71. BeaSan95 on September 23, 2013: (Reply)

    I wish Reese’s were easier to find and not so expensive here…D:

  72. nyxxie023 on September 30, 2013: (Reply)

    Yeah seriously. Yoyo Max would be a super cute bakery name.

  73. PuffyFluffyRockz on October 1, 2013: (Reply)

    NO move to Washington!

  74. Scorpio Ignitius on October 5, 2013: (Reply)

    Stay in Canada, you are who you are.

  75. PuffyFluffyRockz on October 5, 2013: (Reply)

    I would make these and then put something marshmallow or maybe banana and
    it would be like the frikkin 8th wonder of the world.

  76. edmond fajardo on October 6, 2013: (Reply)

    U should open ur very own bakery!:)

  77. beccamarch56 on October 10, 2013: (Reply)

    U are talented its ashame u use cups (im british i dont use cups) D:

  78. cele657 on October 14, 2013: (Reply)

    i laughed at that xD great idea

  79. Mary Joy Gul on October 14, 2013: (Reply)

    NO move to Georgia!!!!

  80. quaya c on December 4, 2014: (Reply)

    These would be heaven right now!

  81. Alexia Villanueva on December 21, 2014: (Reply)

    The ones with the oreos are called sluty brownies

Comment on Brownie Reese’s Cookie Cups?

Your email address will not be published.