Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookie Brownie Bites

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (54 votes, average: 4.72 out of 5)

These Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookie Brownie Cups are the perfect way to use up all the Reese’s cups you might have left over from Halloween.

To print this recipe or for more of my gluten free recipes visit the EZGlutenFree blog at

Find me:

Recipe Ingredients:
• 12 Reese’s cups
• For the Peanut Butter Cookie Dough:
• 2/3 of a cup gluten free flour
• ¼ tsp baking powder
• ¼ tsp baking soda
• 1/8 tsp salt
• ¼ cup butter (well softened)
• ¼ cup peanut butter (well softened)
• ½ cup brown sugar
• ¼ tsp vanilla
• 1 egg
• ¼ cup mini chocolate chips
• For the Brownie Batter:
• 3/4 cup butter (1 ½ sticks)
• 1 cup sugar
• 3/4 cup cocoa powder
• 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
• 2 eggs, room temperature
• 1/2 cup gluten free flour
• 1/4 teaspoon baking powder

All videos clips and photographs used to make this video were taken by Anne Colagioia. No other entity has been granted exclusive rights to use any portion of this video. The music clips I used are called “Sunshine A ” and “Golly Gee” by Kevin MacLeod at It’s Royalty Free Music used with permission under a Creative Commons license

«« Previous post
Healthy Fudge Brownie Overnight Oats Recipe | How To Make High Protein Overnight Oatmeal
Next post »»

31 Comments for Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookie Brownie Bites

  1. Cooking with Cricket (cricket516) on November 11, 2015: (Reply)

    These look sooooo good. A must try!

  2. joyfuldenay on November 11, 2015: (Reply)

    I knew it was a mistake to watch this at ten o’clock while lying in bed,
    because now I want some chocolate. They look wonderful. I would never have
    leftover Reese’s candy as they are eaten immediately on sight. Great

  3. Steve's Kitchen on November 11, 2015: (Reply)

    MICHELE AND I ATE THESE.. ;o) Not often you can say that. I reckon the
    chances someone from Australia is Eating something that was baked for a
    Youtube Channel in the USA is 1 in a Million and I can say that these were
    1 in a million to eat.

    Sweet and moreish but that’s what I want with a cup of coffee on a chilly
    Philadelphian winters day.. Thanks Anne XX

    Steve and Michele

  4. In The Kitchen With Jonny on November 11, 2015: (Reply)

    Omg! They look wonderful. Great recipe

  5. Ray Mack's Kitchen and Grill on November 11, 2015: (Reply)

    Awesome channel and AWESOME recipe…We love you. I could eat Reese cup

  6. FitAnge S on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    My goodness! Those look magnificent and how wonderful you got to meet Steve
    and Michelle , steve is wonderful we love in the same city and not far from
    each other either.

  7. Vivi Curiel on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    wow yummy I just made a chocolate brownie crust krusties brand gf with
    pumpkin chocolate cheesecake squares but I gotta try this next your so
    inspiring thank you

  8. One Kitchen - A Thousand Ideas on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    Oh wauw. They look so yummy Anne!

  9. homemade recipes on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    yummy!! they looks soooo delicious tfs??

  10. bjay1956 on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    This looks real awesome indeed, cheers for this great recipe, thanks, John

  11. TheWolfePit on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    Sooooooooo rich and delicious Anne! YUMBO!

  12. Vincenzos Plate on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    This is a bomb of happiness Anne.
    I would love to have this for breakfast tomorrow. I eat sweets for
    breakfast. yum

  13. No Hippie BBQ & Cooking on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    that was very creative. I’m sure they were great

  14. OldManCooking on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    WoW! Those look Fabo Anne! and Gluten free at that.. :)

  15. Kulinary Kreations By Kelly on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    Those look delicious Anne! I love Reese Cups! So this is right up my alley!
    TFS :))

  16. Neil Devine on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    Anne, they look awesome. Nothing better than peanut butter and chocolate.
    Great recipe. Thanks. Neil.

  17. NaturesFairy on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    They look amazing Anna!! I love Reeses PB cups. What a great idea to use up
    the left over candy!! YUM!! WOW how awesome that you got to meet Steve and
    Michele! What a great surprise!! So happy for you! Hugs,, Brenda

  18. Juanelo1946 on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    Anne, these are astoundingly decadent and delicious!! To begin with, who
    doesn’t love Reese peanut butter cups!? It’s best if I not even think of
    your peanut butter cookie brownies, because I have no self control! I would
    devour an entire dozen if those were placed before me! Thanks for sharing a
    great recipe with us! Maybe I could have just one… hmmm

  19. Eat East Indian on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    You make it look so easy Anne..Loved the use of icecream scooper to add
    batter into muffin peanut butter loving family will surely love
    it..not that my leftover reese’s pieces from halloween will be ignored..
    Would love to see you and Steve together in kitchen 🙂 Must have been a
    great time for you guys to be together.

  20. Victoria Paikin on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    Great recipe I like Peanut Butter cups!

  21. TosTinMan EasyCooking on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    Wow! Those look awesome Anne!

  22. Chef Stef on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    Oh my YUM!! Awesome, Anne!!!!! I could eat all of those.
    How fun that Steve came over!

  23. Karen Cas on November 12, 2015: (Reply)


  24. MaryEllen After 60 on November 12, 2015: (Reply)

    I purposely waited until after I had dinner to watch this video. I think
    you’ve outdone yourself with yumminess. Many blessings, and much

  25. sagedwoman333 on November 14, 2015: (Reply)

    great channel my new friend, so I subbed you
    would you sub me back?
    with thanks

  26. Eli Dobrev on November 15, 2015: (Reply)

    OMG! I was browsing YouTube until i found this piece of heaven! I’m so glad
    that someone has a channel just for Gluten Free Recipes!… I’ve been
    diagnosed with Celiac Disease since 2012, and i’ve been struggling a lot
    since here in Puerto Rico there are not a lot of Gluten Free products, but
    the ingredients only! And now thanks to your videos, i’m able to use those
    recipes! Thank you so much! And blessings! :)

  27. FunFoods on November 15, 2015: (Reply)

    You know I love both Chocolate and Reese’s so this is my dream dessert. But
    if I make them I would eat them all myself. Lol. Steve and Michele are
    terrific people. Glad you had a wonderful time with them.

  28. Scoff on November 16, 2015: (Reply)

    We love the look of these! Can’t wait to try

  29. AllasYummyFood on November 17, 2015: (Reply)

    ooh wow great mix!!! yummy!!!

  30. Haniela's on November 18, 2015: (Reply)

    These look so yummy!

  31. Gluten Free: Back to Basics on November 19, 2015: (Reply)

    Um..can you send me some of those? lol wow. Dearest Anne you are a true
    artist. This is without a doubt an “epic” treat! Outstanding!

Comment on Reese’s Peanut Butter Cookie Brownie Bites?

Your email address will not be published.